eating indie in indy

Posts tagged “sauteed mushrooms

5 Guys Burgers 48 E. Washington Street

Yep we were definitely out of our bailiwick this time. Pat was so insistant I figured they had to have something to offer. What I found was an overpriced Steak and Shake without the ambiance. Pat’s single was over 7 bucks and my double burger was more than $8. They do give you a bunch of fries for $3.69 but they were tepid and had an old oil taste to them. Their primary hook is they offer sauteed mushroom and onions as free toppings but that wouldn’t be enough to entice me back.

THIS IS PROBABLY HALF OF THE ORIGINAL AMOUNT OF FRIES WE WERE GIVEN. WE BOTH ATE A FEW BEFORE I REMEMBERED THE PICTURE.

So in summation I don’t see anything worth going back for. I probably should try another location to satisfy my curiosity but I don’t know that I am that curious.


Ice House 2352 S. West St.

This is indeed a bar. A tavern. I am sure some folks would call it a dive. They would be wrong. It is a big old-fashioned place that sells Adult beverages and well made food. They aren’t too worried about food trends and I am sure no one in the kitchen dreams of James Beard. The bartenders and servers are just that; not mixologists or Flairtenders. They have done the job for a while and do it with both professionalism and a smile. I am a big fan.

The Ice House is a big building sitting in an industrial area all by itself with the sign on top of the building. Like a road house from days gone by.

They always have a big lunch crowd when we go there. If you try their food I think you will see why.

This joint changed owners a few years back and the prices are indeed fancy. The double Pat got was $12.50; but when you consider the extras they include and the fact they only charge $.75 for cheese I guess it balances out. The real values are in their specials. On Wednesday they offer a 6 ounce fillet for $10.95. Included in the price is a salad and a hash brown potato casserole.

Several taverns offer a 6 ounce fillet for 10 to 11 bucks but this one; I believe; is the best around. Moist and tender. Hot with just the right amount of char and most importantly it was cooked mid rare. The potatoes were an interesting dish. It was tasty but I just didn’t want that many carbs for lunch.

Another big item on their menu is broasted chicken. For that you will need a hardy appetite. I really enjoy this place. People talk a lot about “keeping it real.” Well this is one joint that does nothing but. Keep it real.

Ice House Menu, Reviews, Photos, Location and Info - Zomato